Originally posted by Angelo Roncalli
View Post
PAC-10 had one with the Big-12 -- the mismatch of numbers meant that two PAC-10 schools had to play two games, instead of one, with members of the Big-12. The series got dropped in 2010 and it might have been the PAC-10 that didn't want to renew it.
There was a Big East-SEC challenge series which has now played itself out with the BE's split into two different conferences.
The granddaddy of the challenge series is the ACC-Big 10. Like all of the challenge series, it was dreamt up by sports broadcasting industry. They're going to have fun figuring out how to get those games to match up since ACC grows to 15 members this coming year, and Big 10 will have 12.
The RPIs of our bottom-dwellers are worse than those of the Big East's, but take a look at the C7 members of the New Big East, which run from the 2nd ranked school in the Old Big East down to that league's 15th ranked school. DePaul, which had an overall RPI ranking of 202 with its 11-21 win-loss record.
2 (10) Georgetown 0.6315 25-6
3 (12) Marquette 0.6258 23-8
9 (51) Villanova 0.5772 19-13
10 (89) Providence 0.5454 17-14
11 (93) St. John's 0.544 16-15
13 (130) Seton Hall 0.5195 15-18
15 (202) DePaul 0.4771 11-21
Take a look at the Old Big East schools who won't be around anymore, though I'm sure some coaches or AD's might try to continue some historic rivalries as part of their ooc planning.
1 (3) Louisville
4 (13) Syracuse
5 (36) Notre Dame
6 (43) Pittsburgh
7 (49) Connecticut
8 (50) Cincinnati
12 (109) Rutgers
14 (151) South Florida
Are you starting to see a problem? I sure do. Some significant strength that "was" a part of the Old Big East isn't going to be there anymore. Granted, there will be the two added teams from the A-10 and one from the MVC
Moving over from the A-10
2 (20) Butler .6133 (Butler was ranked behind St. Louis in the A-10)
9 (90) Xavier .5451
Moving over from the MVC
1 (25) Creighton .6046
The idea of a challenge series is to compete for overall conference bragging rights between two conferences over a period of years. TV execs arranging these things probably wouldn't want to match a Gonzaga to DePaul. Who's going to want to watch that? If the challenge series matched all teams in each annual event, the organizers would probably try to keep the matchups somewhat comparable, from top to bottom. But the series could also cherry pick the teams participating and their matchups. Here's what the WCC looks like:
1 (6) Gonzaga 0.6368
2 (30) Saint Mary's 0.6004
3 (65) Brigham Young 0.5573
4 (97) Santa Clara 0.5405
5 (160) San Diego 0.5074
6 (166) San Francisco 0.5034
7 (207) Pepperdine 0.4733
8 (208) Loyola Marymount 0.4726
9 (231) Portland 0.4629
Comment