Originally Posted by
JPtheBeasta
Would you accept as fact that there are many factors to play into a yes or no decision? (Does every decision you make depend on a coin flip in your brain, or do certain criteria carry more weight than others? Personally, if I was thinking about jumping out of a plane without a parachute, this is not a 50/50 "jump or not jump" proposition). If this is not an acceptable example, would you accept that there are many factors that go into a team winning a game, or a player making a shot?
By your logic, it seems that every team would be .500 (Win or Not), and every shooter would be 50% (Make it or Not)
Also, the Zag or Not scenario seems to be meaningful at face value, but is arbitrary, because there many more than 2 possible outcomes that have to be considered, all with their own probabilities:
1. Zag or Not
2. College basketball for another team or Not (each team he is considering would have to be included here)
3. Pro basketball or Not
4. Play football or Not (for any number of teams, so each team he is considering would have to be included here)
5. Sit out and prepare for the draft or Not